Taster’s Club Best Rye Whiskeys

One of the masterpieces by Master Distiller Eddie Russel is Wild Turkey Rare Breed Rye– a seamless blend of tradition and innovation. Crafted in small batches, this barrel-proof, non-chill filtered rye whiskey matures to perfection in charred oak barrels, delivering rich complexity and a balanced flavor profile.

A bold yet smooth interplay of spice, oak, and subtle sweetness defines this exceptional spirit, offering a remarkable sipping experience. Whether you want to enjoy it neat, on the rocks, or in your favorite cocktails, Rare Breed Rye stands as a testament to Wild Turkey's commitment to excellence in the world of rye whiskey.

Region: Kentucky | Notes: Herbal, Lemon, Mint, Licorice, Nut, Spice | ABV: 56.1%

2. High West Double Rye

High West Double Rye is a masterfully crafted blend that harmonizes bold rye spice and vibrant botanical notes, revealing layers of freshness and complexity. Aged for a minimum of two years, this distinctive whiskey is a combination of column and pot-still whiskies. Carefully curated to accentuate the remarkable spice character inherent in high rye whiskies, it also offers a refreshing botanical brightness.

The flavor profile is a unique and balanced fusion of cinnamon, gingersnaps, juniper, mint sprigs, and fresh wildflower honey. Perfect for bold sipping, stirring, or savoring, High West Double Rye is a testament to the artistry of whiskey blending.

Region: Utah | Tasting Notes: Oak, mint, eucalyptus, herbal tea | ABV: 46%

3. Pikesville Rye

With roots dating back to the 1890s in Maryland, Pikesville Rye embodies the resilience of a bygone era. Initially halted by Prohibition, it reemerged, standing as the sole survivor of Maryland Rye. Today, produced in Kentucky by Heaven Hill Distillery, Pikesville Rye continues its legacy from extra-aged barrels in optimal warehouse conditions, preserving the rich history of Maryland's once-thriving Rye industry.

Region: Kentucky | Tasting Notes: Dry and spicy, with honeyed rye | ABV: 55%

4. Redemption Rye

Uncover the essence of Redemption Rye with every sip—a journey into the intricate world of the best rye whiskey. Boasting a remarkable 95% rye content, far exceeding the 51% threshold, this expression revives the timeless American whiskey that once graced our glasses before the era of Prohibition. Each nuanced flavor tells a story, inviting you to savor the rich complexity and heritage of this exceptional spirit..

Region: Indiana | Tasting Notes:Oak, Dill, Herbal Spice | ABV: 46%

5. Knob Creek Kentucky Straight Rye Whiskey

This 100-proof rye from Knob Creek was named the World’s Best Rye at the San Francisco World Spirits Competition. It pairs traditional rye spice with the brand’s signature sweetness. With a high corn mash bill, this one’s perfect if you love bourbon but are looking to add rye whisky to your home bar.

Region: Kentucky | Tasting Notes: Fruit, Caramel, Spice, Oak | ABV: 50%

6. Old Forester 100 Proof Rye

WhistlePig Whiskey began its journey into rye whiskey with the Quintessential Rye: the Small Batch Rye, aged 10 years, that started it all. Staying true to its original Master Distiller's vision, it’s a bold, high-rye whiskey with a spice-forward profile that reveals new layers of flavor with every year of aging.

At 100 proof, it’s versatile enough to enjoy however you like—whether sipped neat, over ice or as the star of your favorite cocktail. Crafted with care and a commitment to pushing the boundaries of what rye whiskey can be, it stands as a testament to their passion for creating exceptional spirits.

Region: Kentucky | Tasting Notes: cinnamon stick, dried dill, baked apple | ABV: 50%

7. Sazerac 6 Year Rye

Aged for six years in charred oak barrels, the exceptional Sazerac Rye delivers a robust and refined flavor profile. Warm notes of baking spices, cinnamon, and vanilla blend seamlessly with hints of citrus and pepper, creating a smooth yet bold experience. Perfect for an authentic Sazerac cocktail or enjoying neat, this whiskey promises to elevate any collection with its rich heritage and premium quality.

Region: Kentucky | Tasting Notes: Fruit, Vanilla, Molasses, Apricot Brandy | ABV: 59.11%

8. Michter's US*1 Kentucky Straight Rye

Michter’s is renowned for rye whiskey and takes the production of its US*1 Kentucky Straight Rye with the utmost dedication. The spirit is made from select American rye grain, sheared to maximize the extraction of flavor. On the nose, you’ll get aromas of cherry, green apple, caramel, spice, and oak. You’ll taste similar flavors, along with cinnamon, baking, and citrus, followed by a slow, dry finish.

Region: Kentucky | Tasting Notes: Fruit, Caramel, Spice, Oak | ABV: 42.4%

10. Alberta Premium Cask Strength Rye

One of the best rye whiskey from Alberta Premium, Cask Strength Rye was released to innovate within the Canadian whisky category. Alberta Premium has a rich history of quality and heritage and is proud to be a key part of the comeback of Canadian whiskies, and their award-winning achievement. This expression offers aromas of cinnamon, nutmeg, green tea, and baking spice, followed by a palate of lemon zest, rye spice, berries, and honey with a touch of vanilla and brown sugar.

Region: Canada | Tasting Notes: Lemon Zest, Spice, Berry, Honey | ABV: 66%